{"id":7406,"date":"2021-12-20T00:00:00","date_gmt":"2021-12-19T23:00:00","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/instrid.sk\/uncategorized\/statna-karantena-protiustavna\/"},"modified":"2021-12-20T00:00:00","modified_gmt":"2021-12-19T23:00:00","slug":"statna-karantena-protiustavna","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/instrid.sk\/en\/archiv\/statna-karantena-protiustavna\/","title":{"rendered":"Aktu\u00e1lne: \u0160t\u00e1tna karant\u00e9na je proti\u00fastavn\u00e1, rozhodol tak \u00dastavn\u00fd s\u00fad SR"},"content":{"rendered":"

\u00dastavn\u00fd s\u00fad na neverejnom rokovan\u00ed pl\u00e9na 8. decembra 2021 rozhodol, \u017ee \u0161t\u00e1tna karant\u00e9na nariaden\u00e1 mimo dom\u00e1ceho prostredia je proti\u00fastavn\u00e1.<\/strong><\/p>\n

V nes\u00falade s \u00dastavou Slovenskej republiky je \u010das\u0165 z\u00e1kona naria\u010fuj\u00faca osob\u00e1m izol\u00e1ciu mimo ich dom\u00e1ceho prostredia. \u00dastavn\u00fd s\u00fad skon\u0161tatoval, \u017ee neexistoval d\u00f4vod, aby \u013eudia museli n\u00fatene do \u0161t\u00e1tnej karant\u00e9ny bez alternat\u00edvy izol\u00e1cie doma.<\/strong> N\u00e1lez takto s\u010dasti vyhovel podaniu verejnej ochrankyne pr\u00e1v M\u00e1rie Patakyovej. Ombudsmanka \u00dastavn\u00fd \u0161t\u00e1t \u017eiadala aj o zru\u0161enie mo\u017enosti nariadenia izol\u00e1cie v dom\u00e1com prostred\u00ed, \u010domu s\u00fad nevyhovel.<\/p>\n

Pod\u013ea \u00dastavn\u00e9ho s\u00fadu teda \u0161t\u00e1tna karant\u00e9na poru\u0161uje jedno zo z\u00e1kladn\u00fdch \u013eudsk\u00fdch pr\u00e1v- pr\u00e1vo na osobn\u00fa slobodu.<\/strong> „Izol\u00e1cia v zdravotn\u00edckom zariaden\u00ed, pr\u00edpadne v inom ur\u010denom zariaden\u00ed v spojen\u00ed s leg\u00e1lnou defin\u00edciou izol\u00e1cie, ako aj absencia procesnopr\u00e1vnych z\u00e1ruk osobnej slobody,<\/em>“ priviedli \u00dastavn\u00fd s\u00fad k z\u00e1veru, ktor\u00fd hovor\u00ed o proti\u00fastavnosti. S\u00fad v\u0161ak ministerstvu zdravotn\u00edctva a hygienikom ponechal pr\u00e1vomoc nariadi\u0165 dom\u00e1cu izol\u00e1cie. V tomto pr\u00edpade sa o obmedzenie osobnej slobody nejedn\u00e1.<\/p>\n

Peter Kres\u00e1k, ktor\u00fd je \u00fastavn\u00fd pr\u00e1vnik a poradca verejnej ochrankyne pr\u00e1v, poukazuje na fakt, \u017ee dotknut\u00ed jedinci nemali umo\u017enen\u00e9 na z\u00e1klade \u017eiadneho pr\u00e1vneho predpisu da\u0165 tak\u00e9to nariadenie presk\u00fama\u0165 nez\u00e1visl\u00e9mu s\u00fadnemu org\u00e1nu. Kres\u00e1k skon\u0161tatoval, \u017ee tieto osoby boli v podstate pozbaven\u00e9 pr\u00e1va na spravodliv\u00fd s\u00fadny proces<\/strong>, \u010do nie je zlu\u010dite\u013en\u00e9 s princ\u00edpmi demokratick\u00e9ho a pr\u00e1vneho \u0161t\u00e1tu.<\/p>\n

Patakyov\u00e1 okrem poru\u0161ovania pr\u00e1va na osobn\u00fa slobodu upozor\u0148ovala aj na \u010fal\u0161ie probl\u00e9my, s ktor\u00fdmi sa \u013eudia stret\u00e1vali.<\/p>\n

\u0160t\u00e1tna karant\u00e9na a fakt\u00fary<\/h3>\n

Osoba, ktor\u00e1 sa vr\u00e1tila zo zahrani\u010dia si za ka\u017ed\u00fd de\u0148 v karant\u00e9ne zaplatila 13 eur. Niektor\u00ed v\u0161ak v karant\u00e9ne pobudli aj 20 alebo 25 dn\u00ed. Vyskytli sa v\u0161ak aj dlh\u0161ie pobyty v podobe 50-d\u0148ovej izol\u00e1cie, ktor\u00e1 predstavovala sumu 650 eur.<\/strong> Izolovan\u00ed \u013eudia vo v\u00e4\u010d\u0161ine pr\u00edpadov dokonca nemohli pracova\u0165.<\/p>\n Na \u00fa\u010del izolovania sa v \u0161t\u00e1tnej karant\u00e9ne sl\u00fa\u017eila aj ubytov\u0148a v Gab\u010d\u00edkove, Zdroj foto: ubytovanie-gabcikovo.business.site\n

Fakt\u00fary za \u0161t\u00e1tnu karant\u00e9nu v\u0161ak pod\u013ea \u00dastavn\u00e9ho s\u00fadu maj\u00fa by\u0165 v poriadku. Denn\u00edk Sme vo svojom \u010dl\u00e1nku z 13. decembra informoval, \u017ee za \u0161t\u00e1tnu karant\u00e9nu doposia\u013e nezaplatilo e\u0161te viac ne\u017e 4 000 \u013eud\u00ed, nezaplaten\u00e1 suma spolu \u010din\u00ed viac ne\u017e 425 000 eur.<\/strong><\/p>\n

\u0160t\u00e1t posielal fakt\u00fary opakovane spolu s v\u00fdzvou, \u017ee ak dlh nebude splaten\u00fd, suma bude od nich vym\u00e1han\u00e1.<\/strong> Rozhodnutie \u00dastavn\u00e9ho s\u00fadu o proti\u00fastavnosti \u0161t\u00e1tnej karant\u00e9ny by veci mohlo skomplikova\u0165 \u2013 je teda ot\u00e1zne, \u010di \u0161t\u00e1t bude fakt\u00fary posiela\u0165 aj na\u010falej.<\/p>\n

Nie je v\u0161ak jasn\u00e9, ako to bude \u010falej vyzera\u0165 s vym\u00e1han\u00edm fakt\u00far za izol\u00e1ciu v \u0161t\u00e1tnej karant\u00e9ne. Ministerstvo vn\u00fatra rie\u0161i pr\u00edpady zatia\u013e len mimos\u00fadne. Obdr\u017ealo aj 9 \u017eiadost\u00ed o odpustenie platby, ktor\u00e9 m\u00f4\u017eu poch\u00e1dza\u0165 napr\u00edklad aj od soci\u00e1lne slab\u0161\u00edch skup\u00edn.<\/strong> T\u00fdmto \u017eiadate\u013eom umo\u017enilo vyrovna\u0165 si svoj dlh v podobe spl\u00e1tok.<\/p>\n

Ako to teda bude s fakt\u00farami na\u010falej nie je zn\u00e1me, av\u0161ak tla\u010dov\u00e9 vyhl\u00e1senie, nazna\u010duje, \u017ee fakt\u00fary sa za proti\u00fastavn\u00e9 nepova\u017euj\u00fa. N\u00e1klady s\u00fa toti\u017eto skuto\u010dn\u00e9 a zah\u0155\u0148aj\u00fa aj stravu, ktor\u00fa \u013eudia dostali.<\/strong><\/p>\n

Verejn\u00e1 ochranky\u0148a pr\u00e1v M\u00e1ria Patakyov\u00e1 v\u0161ak rozhodnutie s\u00fadu aj tak ozna\u010dila za v\u00fdznamn\u00e9. \u201eV\u00edtam rozhodnutie \u00dastavn\u00e9ho s\u00fadu, v ktorom sa zhodol s podstatnou \u010das\u0165ou m\u00f4jho podania. Ide o v\u00fdznamn\u00e9 rozhodnutie, ke\u010f\u017ee \u00dastavn\u00fd s\u00fad po prv\u00fdkr\u00e1t od vypuknutia pand\u00e9mie <\/em>merit\u00f3rne vyslovil nes\u00falad ustanoven\u00ed z\u00e1kona o ochrane verejn\u00e9ho zdravia s \u00fastavou,<\/em>\u201c\u00a0uviedla Patakyov\u00e1.<\/p>\n

Karant\u00e9nne ubytovanie je v\u0161ak st\u00e1le mo\u017enos\u0165ou<\/h3>\n

Aj napriek tomu, \u017ee \u0161t\u00e1tnu karant\u00e9nu Slovensko u\u017e stihlo zru\u0161i\u0165, aj dnes je mo\u017en\u00e9 izolova\u0165 sa mimo dom\u00e1ceho prostredia aj v tzv. karant\u00e9nnom ubytovacom zariaden\u00ed. Av\u0161ak, zo slobodnej v\u00f4le. Jedn\u00e1 sa o pr\u00edpady, kedy osoba pozit\u00edvna na ochorenie COVID-19 nem\u00e1 mo\u017enos\u0165 zosta\u0165 v karant\u00e9ne sama a nechce ohrozi\u0165 rodinu \u010di \u010fal\u0161ie osoby, ktor\u00e9 s \u0148ou \u017eij\u00fa v jednej dom\u00e1cnosti.<\/strong> Izol\u00e1cia sa a\u017e na v\u00fdnimky vy\u017eaduje aj od v\u0161etk\u00fdch neo\u010dkovan\u00fdch os\u00f4b proti covidu-19, ktor\u00e9 sa do krajiny vr\u00e1tili zo zahrani\u010dia.<\/p>\n

Poskytovanie karant\u00e9nneho ubytovania sa zara\u010fuje medzi v\u00fdnimky aj po\u010das v\u0161eobecn\u00e9ho uzavretia hotelov a penzi\u00f3nov v d\u00f4sledku nepriaznivej pandemickej situ\u00e1cie.<\/p>\n

Sources:<\/strong> Sme, Pravda, Noviny, Hospod\u00e1rske noviny, Verejn\u00fd ochranca pr\u00e1v, Topky<\/p>\n

Zdroj titulnej fotografie:<\/strong> Unsplash\/ Erik Mclean<\/p>","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"

\u00dastavn\u00fd s\u00fad na neverejnom rokovan\u00ed pl\u00e9na 8. decembra 2021 rozhodol, \u017ee \u0161t\u00e1tna karant\u00e9na nariaden\u00e1 mimo dom\u00e1ceho prostredia je proti\u00fastavn\u00e1. V nes\u00falade s \u00dastavou Slovenskej republiky<\/p>","protected":false},"author":1,"featured_media":0,"comment_status":"closed","ping_status":"closed","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"footnotes":""},"categories":[51],"tags":[],"class_list":["post-7406","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","hentry","category-archiv","two-columns"],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/instrid.sk\/en\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/7406","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/instrid.sk\/en\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/instrid.sk\/en\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/instrid.sk\/en\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/1"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/instrid.sk\/en\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=7406"}],"version-history":[{"count":0,"href":"https:\/\/instrid.sk\/en\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/7406\/revisions"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/instrid.sk\/en\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=7406"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/instrid.sk\/en\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=7406"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/instrid.sk\/en\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=7406"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}